Friday, March 22, 2019
Good Citizen vs. Good Man :: essays research papers
penny-pinching Citizen vs. Good Man The corking creation and the intimately citizen atomic number 18 not iodin and the same. What can be said about one cannot be needs said about the early(a). It is essential for the good man to be a good citizen. It is not, though, vital for the good citizen to be a good man. This quality is important to make, because it helps one understand that the qualities a good man possesses farther supersede those of a good citizen. A good citizen does what is best for the community, his city. As long as he is no harm to his surroundings, and cares for the improvement and advancement of his city, he is a good citizen. Who a person is doesnt greatly chance upon what kind of citizen he will be. What if a man is a out of sight murderer? If we were to say that he only kills people outside of his city, would he be affecting the city in whatever way? If he was a great politician and lived this secret life as come up would he still be a great citizen ? The answer is yes. This is because the good citizen doesnt have to care about others. He can throw overboard his desires to pass his calculating. He doesnt have to have a well-ordered soul. In other words, he doesnt have to be a good man. Aristotle chooses to search for the variation between the good man and the good citizen by examining and analyzing their meritoriousnesss. He concludes that, "Hence, the integrity of a citizen must be suited to his constitution. Consequently, if indeed there are several kinds of constitution, it is clear that there cannot be a hit virtue that is the virtue-of a good citizen. But the good man, we say, does express a single virtue the complete one. Evidently, then, it is possible for someone to be a good citizen without having acquired the virtue expressed by a good man" (1276b). What Aristotle doesnt guarantee us is who is better off. Is it sufficient to be the good citizen or is it definitely more satisfying to be the good man? Th e good man is recognizably superior to the good citizen. The good man possesses everything that is good. He does what is clean and what is just is beneficial to himself and to those around him. His soul is completely well-ordered and, therefore, cannot allow for his desires to take over and commit evil or injustice of any kind.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment